Human Rights Act 1993 No 82 (as at 01 October 2008), Public Act

70 Superannuation schemes
  • (1) Subject to subsection (3) of this section, nothing in section 22 or section 44 of this Act relating to different treatment on the ground of age or disability shall apply to any condition in, or requirement of, a superannuation scheme in existence at the commencement of this Act in relation to a person who was a member of the scheme at the commencement of this Act or who becomes a member of the scheme before the 1st day of January 1996.

    (2) It shall continue to be lawful for the provisions of a superannuation scheme to provide—

    • (a) Different benefits for members of each sex on the basis of the same contributions; or

    • (b) The same benefits for members of each sex on the basis of different contributions,—

    if the different treatment—

    • (c) Is based on actuarial or statistical data, upon which it is reasonable to rely, relating to life-expectancy, accidents, or sickness; and

    • (d) Is reasonable having regard to the applicability of the data, and of any other relevant factors, to the particular circumstances.

    (3) It shall continue to be unlawful to require an applicant for membership of a superannuation scheme to have attained a minimum age.

    (4) Nothing in section 22 or section 44 of this Act shall prevent the provisions of a superannuation scheme from—

    • (a) Providing or requiring different contributions for members; or

    • (b) Providing benefits for members that differ in nature or amount,—

    by reason of the disability or age of those members, if the different treatment—

    • (c) Is based on—

      • (i) Actuarial or statistical data, upon which it is reasonable to rely, relating to life-expectancy, accidents, or sickness; or

      • (ii) Where no such data is available in respect of persons with a disability, reputable medical or actuarial advice or opinion, upon which it is reasonable to rely, whether or not contained in an underwriting manual; and

    • (d) Is reasonable having regard to the applicability of the data or advice or opinion, and of any other relevant factors, to the particular circumstances.

    (5) Nothing in section 22 or section 44 of this Act shall prevent the provisions of a superannuation scheme, or the trustees of the scheme, from—

    • (a) Requiring an applicant for membership of the scheme to be under a specified maximum age; or

    • (b) Permitting a member of the scheme to elect to make increased or reduced contributions to the scheme either temporarily or indefinitely; or

    • (c) Specifying an age of eligibility for each type of benefit provided for members of the scheme; or

    • (e) Providing benefits on the death or disability of members of the scheme that decrease in value as the age of members increases; or

    • (f) Providing benefits for members of the scheme that differ in nature and amount according to the member's period of membership (including any period deemed by the trustees of the scheme to be membership) of the scheme and of any scheme replaced by that scheme, and, in the case of a superannuation scheme provided by an employer, of any scheme to which the employer has paid contributions on behalf of the employee.

    (6) In assessing for the purposes of this section whether it is reasonable to rely on any data or advice or opinion and whether different treatment is reasonable, the Commission or the Complaints Division may—

    • (a) Require justification to be provided for reliance on the data or advice or opinion and for the different treatment; and

    • (b) Request the views of the Government Actuary on the justification for the reliance and for the different treatment.

    Subsection (1) was amended, as from 9 December 1994, by section 6 Human Rights Amendment Act 1994 (1994 No 138) by substituting 1st day of January 1996 for 1st day of January 1995.

    Subsection (5)(d) was amended, as from 12 October 2001, by section 77 New Zealand Superannuation Act 2001 (2001 No 84) by substituting under section 7 of the New Zealand Superannuation Act 2001 for under section 3 of the Social Welfare (Transitional Provisions) Act 1990.

    Subsection (5)(d) was amended, as from 21 April 2005, by section 9(1) New Zealand Superannuation and Retirement Income Amendment Act 2005 (2005 No 42) by substituting New Zealand Superannuation and Retirement Income Act 2001 for New Zealand Superannuation Act 2001.