Gas Governance (Compliance) Regulations 2008 (SR 2008/253) (as at 04 December 2008)

19 Factors to be taken into account when determining materiality
  • (1) The market administrator must, in determining whether or not an alleged breach raises a material issue, take into account the following factors, to the extent that they are practical or relevant:

    • (a) the severity of the alleged breach:

    • (b) whether the alleged breach had a material impact on the operation of the market:

    • (c) the extent to which the breach was inadvertent, negligent, deliberate, or otherwise:

    • (d) whether the participant allegedly in breach took remedial action immediately upon, or soon after, discovery of the breach:

    • (e) whether the alleged breach has a potential anti-competitive effect:

    • (f) whether the alleged breach has resulted in costs being borne by other participants or persons:

    • (g) whether the alleged breach is admitted:

    • (h) whether the alleged breach was an isolated event, or indicates a systemic problem with compliance with the rules:

    • (ha) the extent to which the breach was caused by an event or circumstance beyond the reasonable control of the participant allegedly in breach:

    • (i) whether the breach allegation is frivolous or vexatious or is not made in good faith:

    • (j) whether, considering the length of time that has elapsed, an investigation of the alleged breach is no longer practicable or desirable:

    • (k) whether the participant allegedly in breach is, or has been, subject to any other orders under the Act or these regulations:

    • (l) the likelihood that the same breach or a similar breach may occur in the future:

    • (m) whether the participant allegedly in breach has benefited from the breach:

    • (n) whether the complexity of the facts warrant investigation:

    • (o) any other factors that the market administrator considers relevant.

    (2) The market administrator may publish guidelines to illustrate how it is weighting and applying these factors.

    Regulation 19(1)(ha): inserted, on 4 December 2008, by regulation 8 of the Gas Governance (Compliance) Amendment Regulations 2008 (SR 2008/427).