General policy statement
This Bill is an omnibus Bill that makes amendments to the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 (the FMC Act) and the Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Act 2008 (the FSP Act). It also repeals the Financial Advisers Act 2008 (the FA Act) and revokes associated regulations and notices.
The purpose of this Bill is to ensure that financial services are provided in a way that promotes the confident and informed participation of businesses, investors, and consumers. To achieve this, it makes amendments to ensure that the conduct and client-care obligations of financial service providers and the regulation of financial markets remain fit for purpose. It also addresses misuse of the financial service providers register (the FSPR) by offshore entities.
Creating a new regulatory regime for financial advice
The Bill creates a new regulatory regime for the provision of financial advice. The new regime has been designed in response to the findings of a statutorily required review of the operation of—
the FA Act, which regulates the provision of financial advice; and
the FSP Act, which sets dispute resolution and registration requirements for financial service providers.
The review found a number of problems with the existing regime for financial advice, which are hindering investor confidence, participation in financial markets, and informed decision making.
The new regime addresses those problems in a way that will—
ensure consumers can access the financial advice they need:
improve the quality of financial advice:
not impose any undue compliance costs, complexity, or barriers to innovation:
ensure access to redress.
The Bill—
enables the provision of more types of financial advice. Unlike the FA Act, the Bill is technology-neutral. This means that the existing restriction that some types of advice need to be given by a natural person will be lifted. This fully enables the provision of robo-advice (online advice) and helps future-proof the regime for technological developments. In addition, the Bill removes the existing distinction between types of financial advice services (for example, class and personalised services). This will make it easier for those giving advice to tailor the advice to the client, rather than be bound by regulatory boundaries:
establishes an even playing field and more proportionate conduct and competence requirements. The Bill requires all individuals and robo-advice platforms giving financial advice to place the interests of the consumer first. All those giving financial advice to retail clients will also be required to provide advice only where competent to do so, and be subject to a code of conduct that sets minimum standards of competence, knowledge, skill, ethical behaviour, and client care. While similar requirements exist under the FA Act, they only apply to authorised financial advisers who are a small subset of those who give advice:
requires that the code of conduct include minimum standards of competence, knowledge, and skill that apply to particular types of financial advice and products, recognising that the broadened application of the code will mean different and additional standards will be appropriate in some cases:
aligns the definition of a wholesale client with the FMC Act definition of wholesale investor. Wholesale clients are generally large or sophisticated clients such as banks, investment businesses, or high-net-worth individuals who do not require or benefit from the same degree of protection as retail clients. Aligning the definition in this way will reduce complexity and result in fewer individuals being classified as wholesale when they really need the protections of a retail client:
requires all those giving financial advice to retail clients (rather than just some advisers, as under the FA Act) to ensure their clients understand any limitations on the nature and scope of the advice provided. For example, how many products or how many providers they have considered:
requires anyone providing financial advice to retail clients to operate under a licence under Part 6 of the FMC Act. To ensure this does not impose undue costs on industry or government, licences will be able to be issued at the firm level. The specific licensing requirements will be set in regulations and by the Financial Markets Authority (the FMA). The requirements will be flexible depending on factors such as the size and nature of a firm and the services it provides, and whether a firm engages financial advisers or nominated representatives, or is a sole trader:
limits who can give regulated financial advice. The Bill requires that in order to give regulated financial advice an individual must be either a financial adviser or a nominated representative both of whom must be giving advice on behalf of a financial advice provider:
provides that financial advice providers will be subject to the FMC Act’s compliance and enforcement tools such as civil pecuniary penalties for various breaches, and licensed providers will be subject to licensing actions such as censure and the imposition of action plans. This introduces consistency in approach to enforcement for all licensed financial services:
maintains disciplinary measures for some individuals. Financial advisers will be subject to the financial advisers’ disciplinary committee (the Disciplinary Committee). If a financial adviser is found to have contravened any obligation, the Disciplinary Committee will be able to censure, impose conditions, require the adviser to undergo training, impose a fine of up to $10,000, or direct the Registrar of Financial Service Providers (the Registrar) to deregister, or suspend the registration of, the financial adviser:
requires disclosure of prescribed information to clients. The Bill requires those giving financial advice to disclose certain information to retail and wholesale clients. The content, timing, and manner of disclosure will be prescribed in regulations and may differ from the existing requirements:
exempts some persons from the regulatory requirements. The Bill carries over the exclusions (or exemptions) from the FA Act, which exempt some persons from being subject to regulation even if they provide financial advice. This applies to some occupations if the financial advice they give is given in the ordinary course of carrying on that occupation. The Bill also introduces a limited exclusion for lenders giving advice reasonably for the purposes of complying with certain lender responsibility obligations under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003:
carries over the regulation of brokers from the FA Act, but replaces that term with people who provide a client money or property service. No additional obligations are applied to this service, nor is a market services licence required to provide this service.
In addition to the key elements of the Bill outlined above, which seek to achieve the Government’s objectives for a financial advice regime in New Zealand, the Bill includes the following transitional provisions to expedite and simplify implementation of the new regime.
Transitional licences
The Bill requires industry participants to be engaged by a firm with a transitional licence on a date to be set by Order in Council (expected to be approximately 9 months after the code of conduct is approved). At this point, most elements of the new regime, including the legislative duties and enforcement mechanisms, would take effect. However, existing industry participants who do not meet the competence standards in the code of conduct will be protected by a safe harbour, recognising that it may take time for some to meet any new competence standards.
The transitional licensing process will require industry participants to satisfy a narrower set of entry criteria than the full licensing process. This will enable industry to move to the new regime quickly.
The Bill provides for transitional licences and the safe harbour to expire after 2 years. At this stage, all industry participants would be required to be engaged by a firm with a full licence and everyone would be required to meet the competence standards in the code of conduct.
Code working group
The Bill enables a code working group to prepare the code of conduct, as if it were the code committee (to be established under Part 4 of new Schedule 5 of the FMC Act), before the passage of the Bill. This enables the code of conduct to be developed earlier than would otherwise be possible, expediting transition to the new regime. The new code will replace the existing code of conduct, made under the FA Act.
Discretionary investment management services
The Bill requires authorised financial advisers who provide personalised discretionary investment management services (DIMS) under the FA Act to be regulated under the FMC Act if they wish to continue providing DIMS. This avoids DIMS being regulated in 2 slightly different ways under the same Act. To ensure minimal disruption the Bill enables the existing personalised DIMS providers to be automatically granted FMC Act licences, subject to conditions.
Requiring a stronger connection to New Zealand to be registered on FSPR
The Bill introduces more stringent requirements for entities wanting to register on the FSPR. Entities will only be able to register if they are in the business of providing financial services to persons in New Zealand or otherwise required to be licensed or registered under any other New Zealand legislation.
The Bill also introduces other mechanisms to reduce the risk of misuse of the register, such as providing a regulation-making power in relation to the statements that can be made about a provider’s registration, and providing a power for the Registrar to require information from persons other than the provider, such as a director of the provider.
Other amendments to FMC Act
The Bill includes other minor changes and improvements to the FMC Act as follows. These amendments address issues that have emerged since the implementation of the Financial Markets Conduct regime. The changes will help ensure that the policy of the Act is efficiently and effectively achieved and promote confident and informed participation of businesses, investors, and consumers.
In particular, the Bill—
provides for the approval of single person retirement schemes as a Schedule 3 scheme to be cancelled under specific circumstances including when retirement age is reached:
provides for redeemable shares issued by industrial and provident societies to be treated as equity securities (shares):
provides discretion for the FMA to delay publication of exemptions where a risk of commercial prejudice may arise from earlier publication:
makes a minor amendment to the same class exclusion for offers by way of sale, to ensure the exclusion properly reflects market practice in relation to issues of financial products conducted as secondary sales.