General policy statement
Overview
The Forests (Legal Harvest Assurance) Amendment Bill is intended to establish a new regulatory system for providing legal harvest assurance for the forestry and wood-processing sector. It is expected to operate in a manner that will—
assist in the prevention of international trade in illegally harvested timber; and
strengthen the international reputation of the New Zealand forestry and wood-processing sector; and
safeguard and enhance market access for New Zealand forestry exports; and
reduce the risk that timber imported into New Zealand is sourced from illegally harvested timber.
Background
New Zealand is committed to assisting in the prevention of the global trade in illegally harvested timber products. The illegal harvesting of timber is a significant problem globally, contributing to deforestation and ecosystem degradation, with wide-reaching environmental, economic, and social impacts for affected communities.
Forestry is New Zealand’s fourth largest primary sector export earner, generating NZ$6.3 billion for the year ending June 2021. Having confidence in the integrity of the forestry supply chain and the operators within the system is critical for both domestic processing and New Zealand’s reputation as a high-quality exporter of timber products.
New Zealand’s imports of timber products have increased by approximately 70% over the last decade, to $2.35 billion for the year ending June 2021. A rising volume (and diversity of imports) increases the risk of New Zealand becoming a conduit for the illegal timber trade due to a lack of mandatory assurance measures. While New Zealand has had voluntary measures in place since the early 2000s, and there have been proactive initiatives by importers, the coverage has not been complete.
Historically, New Zealand has relied on its reputation of being a low-risk producer of illegal timber products for ensuring market access. However, more recently New Zealand exporters have been required to demonstrate the legality of their timber products in a growing number of export markets.
International environment
The international trading environment is forecast to become more volatile in the wake of COVID-19, and the resulting disruptions to trade and economic activity. The initiatives proposed in this Bill will work to facilitate trade and support market access by enhancing the reputation of New Zealand’s forestry and wood-processing sector.
Several of New Zealand’s key forestry trading partners—including Australia, United States, Indonesia, Republic of Korea, Japan, Vietnam, the European Union, and China—have implemented, or are developing, their own legislation to prevent the import, export, or trans-shipment of illegally harvested timber. While New Zealand is seen internationally as being a low-risk supplier of illegally harvested timber, our major overseas markets (and their consumers) are increasingly looking for legislation-backed assurances that our timber products have been legally harvested, and there are robust due diligence practices supporting these assurances. For the year ended March 2021, 85% of New Zealand’s total exports of forestry and timber products were to those countries listed above with current or imminent legal harvest regulations.
To support market access, MPI has put in place interim arrangements with several key trading partners. These arrangements are an interim measure until a permanent legal harvest system is put in place. A long-term and consistent solution is required that can meet the requirements of an increasing number of trading partners for a robust legislative framework for legal harvest and provide confidence and certainty for the forestry and wood-processing sector.
Scope of proposed legal harvest system
The legal harvest system will apply to exotic timber and specified timber products. With two exceptions, the legal harvest system will not apply to a person trading in indigenous timber as they are already regulated under Part 3A of the Forests Act 1949 (the Act). In the event that market requirements for indigenous timber change significantly, the Bill will allow regulations to specify certain indigenous timber to be included in the legal harvest system. In addition, the Bill will allow a person dealing with indigenous timber in the domestic supply chain to voluntarily opt into the legal harvest system if there is benefit in doing so.
There are existing private certification schemes that some forest owners use to demonstrate the legality of their production, including schemes by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Programme for Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC).
The reporting requirements and costs associated with private certification have been a barrier to smaller forest owners becoming certified. Smaller forest owners are an important component of the plantation estate, providing an increasing portion of the annual timber harvest over the past 15 years. It is estimated that this trend will continue, with forecasts predicting small growers will provide 40% of the harvest during the 2020s, up from 25.5% in 2015 and just 14% in 2007. The legal harvest system will ensure this timber can continue to be incorporated into the commercial supply chain.
Expected benefits of new system
New Zealand has the opportunity through this Bill, to step up its contribution to preventing the global trade in illegally harvested timber by reducing the risk of illegal timber imports while also ensuring New Zealand’s own timber products are sourced from logs that have been legally harvested. The establishment of a regulatory system in New Zealand will help reduce the adverse global impact of the trade in illegally harvested timber, and help build the reputation of New Zealand’s timber products in export markets.
The introduction of a legal harvest system, with a robust legislative framework and appropriate assessment measures will provide oversight and transparency across both domestically produced and imported timber. The system is expected to deliver a significant net benefit of approximately $690 million over 10 years, primarily through the maintenance of higher value markets (by having a legal harvest system that can meet the legality requirements of importing countries).
Key components of proposed legal harvest system
As part of the proposed legal harvest system, timber importers, exporters, log traders and primary processors will be required to register and establish due diligence systems to demonstrate that the timber they have obtained has been legally harvested. The due diligence system allows for recognition of private certification schemes. Registered parties will use these systems to assess that the timber they are dealing with has been legally harvested and to provide legal harvest information through their supply chain. For New Zealand sourced timber, this starts with the person responsible for the harvest providing a legal harvest statement (and supporting information if required) that may flow through to the exporter. The registered person will use the legal harvest statement to undertake due diligence to assess whether the timber has been legally harvested.
A registered exporter will be able to apply to MPI for an exporter statement to assist with market access. The exporter statement, and any supporting documentation, will form part of the documentation supplied to importing authorities and wholesale customers.
For imported timber products, the importer will use their due diligence system to assess whether the timber they intend to import has been legally harvested.
The Bill, amongst other things, proposes—
a regulatory system and legislative framework with the Secretary (the Director-General of MPI) having functions, powers, and duties as the regulator; and
a definition of legally harvested; and
mandatory registration for log traders, primary processors, exporters of timber products, and importers of timber products (or their agents) who operate above specified thresholds and are not exempted, with voluntary registration available to people who do these activities on a smaller scale; and
obligations on persons responsible for the harvest (meaning a forest owner or person responsible for making the decision to harvest) to complete a legal harvest statement and declaration that confirms the timber is legally harvested; and
requirements on persons required to register to meet a fit and proper person test and establish and maintain a due diligence system in order to minimise the risk that timber or timber products are illegally harvested; and
an administrative and assessment framework, including assessment of the due diligence systems by assessors approved by the Secretary; and
recognition of private certification schemes in the due diligence system; and
powers for the Secretary to provide an exporter statement to a registered exporter or overseas authority and specify export requirements to facilitate trade and support continued market access; and
a principles-based cost recovery framework; and
ability for a regulated party to seek a review of a decision and have appeal rights; and
a graduated approach to compliance and enforcement; and
powers for forestry officers or other officers to carry out inspections, which may lead to investigations and the issue of a search warrant in accordance with Part 4 of the Search and Surveillance Act 2012; and
secondary legislation to give effect to the system; and
a review of the operation of the legal harvest system and legislation no later than 5 years after full commencement and then at least every 10 years after that.
Log traders
The Bill will amend the Act which is administered by MPI. The proposed legal harvest system will have operational overlaps with the regulation of log traders under new Part 2A of the Act (to be inserted by the Forests (Regulation of Log Traders and Forestry Advisers) Amendment Act 2020). To ensure that the 2 systems operate as efficiently as they can, the Bill repeals provisions relevant to log traders in the new Part 2A and inserts a new Part 6 in the Act. The new Part 6 (log traders) has similar provisions to those in Part 2A with some adjustment to align with the operational design for the legal harvest system.
The Bill makes other technical adjustments to Part 2A of the Act, in order to ensure a more effective administration of the log trader and forestry adviser regulatory system.
Commencement of Bill
The Bill will come into force on the earlier of 3 years after Royal assent and a date appointed by the Governor-General by Order in Council. However, the new compliance and enforcement provisions in Part 5 (legal harvest assurance) will come into force 12 months after the rest of the Bill (unless brought into force earlier by Order in Council). This staged approach is to enable the development of enabling regulations and associated rules, the education of regulated parties in this new system, the timely registration of regulated parties, and adequate time to liaise with New Zealand’s trading partners.