General policy statement
Introduction
This is an omnibus Bill introduced under Standing Order 267(1)(a) (dealing with an interrelated topic that can be regarded as implementing a single broad policy).
The single broad policy and purpose of this Bill is to improve compliance and enforcement legislation to deter employers from exploiting migrant workers. The aim is to deter employer non-compliance with immigration and employment law. The related offence and penalty regimes are amended to ensure mirror enforcement regimes for work by both migrants and non-migrants.
This Bill provides a more proportionate and efficient enforcement toolkit for immigration officers and Labour Inspectors to deal with lower-level offending before it becomes more serious. The Bill aligns the powers of the Labour Inspectorate and Immigration New Zealand and supports greater collaboration between the 2 regulators to undertake compliance and enforcement activity.
To achieve that purpose, this Bill—
amends the Immigration Act 2009 to empower immigration officers to request documents to verify that employers of migrant workers are complying with their obligations:
allows Labour Inspectors and immigration officers to issue an infringement notice when employers fail to provide requested information within a reasonable time frame:
establishes new infringement offences under the Immigration Act 2009 and the Employment Relations Act 2000:
amends the Immigration Act 2009 so that the chief executive of the Ministry of Business, Innovation, and Employment can publish the names of employers convicted of immigration offences or issued with infringement notices (and details about the offending):
amends the Companies Act 1993 so that a person convicted of migrant exploitation and people-trafficking offences cannot be a director or manager of a company if the offending was enabled or otherwise related to the use of a company.
This Bill implements the legislative changes the Government announced as a result of the Temporary Migrant Worker Exploitation Review in 2020.
Creating document production power for immigration officers
Employers who support visa applications make commitments about the pay and conditions of the worker. To ensure that employers are meeting those commitments, immigration officers must be able to require relevant employment records.
Immigration officers have some powers of entry and inspection relating to records of employers under section 277 of the Immigration Act 2009. That power allows them to enter an employer’s premises and inspect or copy records or documents under the employer’s control, provided the immigration officer has reasonable grounds to believe there may be information in those records or documents that relates to non-compliance with the Immigration Act 2009 or the deportation liability of a worker.
The new document production power will differ from this entry and inspection power by allowing a desk-based immigration officer to require the production of documents and records to verify that an employer is employing a person in a role, or under conditions, that match those stated in the employer-supported visa application.
The kind of records and documents that immigration officers could request from employers include wages and time records, leave records, employment agreements, bank statements, and financial statements. Those records would allow immigration officers to assess, for example, whether a migrant worker is being paid the salary stated in the employer-supported visa application. The document production power relates only to documents that the employer is obliged to hold under relevant legislation or documents relating to the remuneration or employment conditions of a supported employee.
The information gathered using this power could, in some circumstances, indicate that an employer has breached employment standards or has committed a more serious criminal offence. In those circumstances, immigration officers will be permitted to share the information gathered with the relevant regulator if they consider it will be of assistance.
Allowing Labour Inspectors and immigration officers to issue infringement notices if employers fail to provide requested documents within reasonable time frame
The Labour Inspectorate experiences delays to investigations when employers fail to provide statutory information within a reasonable period. Labour Inspectors currently have 2 production powers under section 229 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, but that section does not stipulate any time frame for compliance with requests for information.
The Bill will amend the Employment Relations Act 2000 to require an employer to comply with a document production request within 10 working days. Labour Inspectors will be able to issue an infringement notice to employers who fail to comply with such a request within 10 working days.
This infringement offence will be replicated in the Immigration Act 2009, to enable immigration officers to similarly issue infringement notices. Giving this power to both Labour Inspectors and immigration officers will help to ensure that employers comply with document requests.
Establishing new infringement offences under Immigration Act 2009
Currently, the Immigration Act 2009 allows employers to be prosecuted for serious migrant exploitation or other offending but does not provide a proportionate enforcement response for less serious or less intentional offences. Lower-level breaches of immigration law exacerbate migrant workers’ vulnerability and may be the precursor to more serious exploitation.
The Bill will amend the Immigration Act 2009 to create 3 new immigration infringement offences to deter lower-level non-compliance by employers that is linked to, or increases the risk of, migrant exploitation. The offences are when an employer—
allows a person who is not entitled under the Immigration Act 2009 to work in the employer’s service:
does not employ a person in accordance with a work-related condition of that person’s visa:
fails to provide documents requested by an immigration officer within a reasonable time frame (discussed in more detail above).
The Bill also provides a new ability for regulations to prescribe an offence as an employment infringement offence under the Immigration Act 2009.
Expanding stand-down list
Under section 223AAA of the Employment Relations Act 2000, the chief executive of the Ministry of Business, Innovation, and Employment (MBIE) publishes comments about employers found in breach of minimum employment standards. This is what is known as the stand-down list. Employers who are named on the stand-down list are prohibited from supporting a visa application for both temporary and residence class visas for the duration of their stand-down period. Currently, the authorisation to publish names of employers and relevant offending details does not extend to employers convicted of offences or issued with infringement notices under the Immigration Act 2009.
To improve compliance with the Immigration Act 2009 and to give migrants and their advisers access to better information about the compliance history of prospective employers, the Bill introduces a new provision into that Act to enable the chief executive of MBIE to publish the names and certain offending details of employers who are convicted of offences or issued with infringement notices under the Immigration Act 2009. The names and offending details could be included on the stand-down list.
Expanding the stand-down list to cover offences under the Immigration Act 2009 will help to prevent employers who breach employment or immigration requirements from supporting a visa application for both temporary entry and residence class visas. An expanded stand-down list will also reduce the need for immigration officers to assess an employer’s compliance with their obligations at each application, and will clearly indicate to employers that they are ineligible to employ migrants under the accreditation process.
Disqualifying persons convicted of migrant exploitation or people trafficking from managing or directing company
Some company directors leverage corporate structures to avoid personal liability and avoid detection while exploiting migrant workers. This Bill will amend section 383 of the Companies Act 1993 so that persons convicted of exploitation under section 351 of the Immigration Act 2009 or people trafficking under section 98D of the Crimes Act 1961 cannot not be directors, promoters, or managers of any company when their offending was enabled by or otherwise related to the use of a company.
Enabling the High Court to make an order to disqualify persons convicted of migrant exploitation or people trafficking from being a director, promoter or manager of any company will help to reduce migrant exploitation. It will prevent people who have been convicted of serious exploitation that involved the use of a company from using company structures in the future. This measure will supplement existing protections, which currently allow persons to be banned from being employers for up to 10 years under the Employment Relations Act 2000.