Part 1
Preliminary provisions
Clause 3 sets out the purposes of the Bill.
Clause 4 provides an overview of the Bill.
Clause 5 defines certain terms used in the Bill.
Clause 6 provides that the Bill binds the Crown.
Clause 7 deals with how the Remuneration Authority must be constituted when it performs certain functions under the Act. It provides that—
when the Remuneration Authority performs its functions under Part 3 (except clause 22(1)), which deals with support services for members of Parliament, and under clause 41(1), which deals with determining the travel entitlements of former Prime Ministers, it must be composed of an additional member appointed under new section 5A of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 and no fewer than 2 other members of the Remuneration Authority:
when it performs its functions under clause 22(1), 38, or 41(3), which relate to determining issues about entitlements, it must be composed of the additional member and 1 other member of the Authority.
New section 5A of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 (inserted by clause 57) requires the additional member appointed to the Remuneration Authority to be a person who has appropriate knowledge, skills, and experience to assist the Authority to perform its functions under Part 3 and clauses 38 and 41 and to ensure that the purposes of Part 3 are achieved.
Clause 7(3) provides that if the additional member appointed under new section 5A of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 is not available at any time that the Remuneration Authority is required to perform its functions under clause 22(1), 38, or 41(3), the chairperson of the Remuneration Authority may nominate another member to act in the additional member's place.
Clause 8 provides for certain provisions of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 to apply to functions of the Remuneration Authority under the Bill. These relate to meetings of the Authority (section 8(3) to (7)), requirements for members and officers of the Authority to maintain secrecy (section 9(1)), the ability of any person or organisation to make written submissions to the Authority in relation to the exercise by the Authority of its functions (section 21(1)), the application of certain provisions of the Commissions of Inquiry Act 1908 and the conferral of such other powers as may be necessary for the purpose of the Authority carrying out its functions (section 25(1) and (3)), and the exclusion of members of the Authority from personal liability for anything done in good faith in the pursuance or intended pursuance of the powers and duties of the Authority (section 29(1)).
Part 2
Salaries and allowances of members of Parliament
Clause 9 requires the Remuneration Authority to determine the salaries and allowances payable to members of Parliament. When the Authority determines salaries and allowances under clause 9 it is constituted in the same way as it is for all other functions it is required to perform under the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 and other enactments; it has 3 members, and 2 members form a quorum (see sections 5 and 8 of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977). Subclause (4) is a permanent appropriation to provide funding for the salaries and allowances of members of Parliament determined by the Remuneration Authority under clause 9 and also for the payments made as income under clause 42 to the surviving spouse or partner or children of a member of Parliament who dies while in office. Permanent appropriations (sometimes referred to as permanent legislative authorities) are authorised by legislation other than an Appropriation Act and continue in effect until revoked by Parliament. The provision of salaries and allowances for members of Parliament through permanent appropriations is for the purpose of supporting the independence of the Remuneration Authority's determination. The existence of a permanent appropriation means that these payments cannot be subject to the parliamentary control that would otherwise apply were they provided through an Appropriation Act.
Clause 10 records that the salaries and allowances under clause 9 have to be determined under section 12 of the Remuneration Authority Act 1977 and that the sections of that Act apply accordingly. Sections of that Act that are relevant to the performance of the Authority's function in setting the salaries and allowances include—
section 16, which requires the Authority to give a copy of the determination to the Speaker, the Prime Minister, and the Leader of the Opposition, and to publish it in the Gazette. The section also provides that the determination is a regulation for the purposes of the Acts and Regulations Publication Act 1989 (which has the effect that the determination is published as a statutory regulation) but not for the purposes of the Regulations (Disallowance) Act 1989 (which has the effect that it is not subject to amendment or disallowance by the House of Representatives):
section 17A, which requires the Authority to consult the Commissioner of Inland Revenue, the Speaker, and the Minister responsible for Ministerial Services before making a determination:
section 18, which sets out criteria that the Authority must have particular regard to, and criteria that it must take into account, in determining the remuneration of members of Parliament. These criteria include the need for fair relativity with levels of remuneration received elsewhere and the need to be fair to taxpayers and the persons whose remuneration is being determined:
section 18A, which requires the Authority to take into account adverse economic conditions and allows the Authority to determine the remuneration at a lower rate than it would otherwise have determined:
section 19, which deals with the frequency with which the Authority must make a determination, including provisions about when a determination may commence and its continuation until superseded by another determination.
Clause 11 re-enacts section 18(1) and (2) of the Civil List Act 1979. The effect of the clause is that the period for which salaries and allowances determined by the Authority are payable to members of Parliament starts on the day after the polling day at the election at which the member is elected (except if the member is returned at an uncontested by-election) and ends on the polling day for the next general election or, if the member leaves Parliament earlier than the next general election, the day on which the member vacates his or her seat.
Clause 12 re-enacts, with modifications, section 18(3) of the Civil List Act 1979. It applies to members who do not seek re-election at a general election or who stand for re-election but are not re-elected. The clause provides for those persons to be paid a salary for the 3-month period starting on the day after polling day at the election. If the person was an ordinary member of Parliament, the salary is paid at the same rate at which an ordinary member's salary was payable as at polling day. The clause differs from section 18(3) of the Civil List Act 1979 in that clause 12(3) clarifies that if the person was a member of the Executive or a Parliamentary Under-Secretary then, for the period starting on the day after polling day and ending on the day that person no longer holds the office (which, under section 6(2)(b) of the Constitution Act 1986, could be up to 28 days), the salary must be paid at the rate that was payable to the holder of that office as at polling day for the election. For the balance of the 3-month period it must be paid at the rate at which an ordinary member of Parliament's salary was payable as at polling day. It also clarifies that if the person was the Speaker or Deputy Speaker then, for the period starting on the day after polling day and ending on the day that the House of Representatives first meets after the general election, the salary must be paid at the rate at which the Speaker or Deputy Speaker's salary was payable as at polling day. For the balance of the 3-month period it is payable at the rate at which an ordinary member of Parliament's salary was payable as at polling day.
Clause 13 deals with the situation where the election of a member of Parliament is questioned in an election petition. It sets out the salaries and allowances that must be paid to a person who loses his or her seat and to the person (if any) who is declared to have been duly elected in the place of that person.
Clause 14 is a modification of section 20 of the Civil List Act 1979. Under that section, an amount of $10 may be deducted from a member's gross salary for every sitting day in excess of 14 on which the member is absent during a session of Parliament (except where the absence is for specified reasons). Under clause 14, an amount may be deducted from a member's gross salary for every sitting day in excess of 9 that a member is absent during a calendar year, other than in accordance with the rules of the House of Representatives. The amount to be deducted is 0.2% of the gross yearly base salary fixed by the Authority under clause 9 for a member of Parliament who is not an office holder. As at 30 June 2011, the gross yearly base salary of an ordinary member of Parliament was $134,800 (see Parliamentary Salaries and Allowances Determination 2010). Under clause 14(2), the amount deductible from the gross salary of any member of Parliament who had been absent from the House without the permission of the Speaker on 30 June 2011 (other than in accordance with the rules of the House) for the tenth sitting day in the calendar year beginning on 1 January 2011 would therefore have been $270.
Clause 15 re-enacts section 21A of the Civil List Act 1979. It provides that a person cannot receive a payment under Part 2 or Part 3 in respect of a period of time if that person also receives a salary as a head of mission or a head of post (within the meaning of the Foreign Affairs Act 1988) in respect of the same period.
Part 3
Services for members of Parliament
Clause 16 sets out the purposes of Part 3 as being to ensure that the entitlements of members of Parliament and Ministers to support services are determined in a way that does a number of specified things, including—
recognising the need for members of Parliament, the Executive, and parties to be adequately supported while at the same time recognising the need to be fair to taxpayers:
recognising the need for public understanding of the work undertaken by members and parties and what they need to do that work:
facilitating effective and efficient delivery of support services:
promoting transparency:
maintaining confidence in the integrity of Parliament:
maintaining the independence of the Remuneration Authority.
Clause 17 specifies criteria that both the Remuneration Authority and the Speaker must have regard to when making determinations and issuing directions under Part 3. These are—
the purposes of Part 3:
the principle that if services provided for members of Parliament include any element of remuneration or other private benefit, that benefit should be taken into account in determining the salaries and allowances of members:
the need for the entitlements to services to be clearly defined so that decisions about whether a person or party is eligible for an entitlement can easily be made:
the need for the entitlements to services to be determined in a way that is consistent with the objectives of efficient and effective delivery of those services:
the need for the entitlements to be simple to administer.
The effect of subclause (2) is that if an entitlement to a service under a determination by the Remuneration Authority or a determination made or directions issued by the Speaker results in an element of personal benefit or potential personal benefit for a member of Parliament, a Minister, or their family members, the value of the benefit must be assessed and that value must be taken into account by the Remuneration Authority when it determines the salaries and allowances of the relevant members of Parliament or Ministers under clause 9. The Remuneration Authority's determination of salaries and allowances must also include a statement that sets out how it has taken the value into account in fixing the salaries and allowances.
Services determined by Remuneration Authority
Clauses 18 to 23 deal with the services that the Remuneration Authority must determine, and matters relating to its determinations.
Clause 18 requires the Remuneration Authority to determine the following:
under clause 18(1)(a), entitlements of members of Parliament and qualifying electoral candidates to all travel and accommodation services, except certain specified services. Members of the Executive are entitled, in their capacity as members of Parliament, to the services determined for all members under this provision:
under clause 18(1)(b), the entitlements of members of the Executive to travel and accommodation services within New Zealand that are in addition or alternative to the entitlements to travel and accommodation services determined for all members of Parliament under clause 18(1)(a):
the extent to which any of these services may continue to be provided, for specified purposes, after a member of Parliament vacates his or her seat or a Minister ceases to be a member of the Executive.
The specified travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament that are not determined by the Remuneration Authority are—
travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament participating in the political exchange programme (see clause 24 concerning these services):
international travel and international accommodation services for members of Parliament travelling internationally for parliamentary purposes where the costs of that travel and accommodation are met from the party and member support appropriation for the party of the member travelling and are a charge against the leadership funding allocation (see clause 24 concerning these services):
international travel and international accommodation services in respect of the inter-parliamentary relations programme (see clause 31 concerning these services):
international travel and international accommodation services for members of the Executive travelling on ministerial business. These services are met by the Department of Internal Affairs, on the basis of approval by Cabinet or the Prime Minister, as business expenses. (Communications services for members of the Executive that are additional or alternative to those that they receive as members of Parliament are also met by that department as business expenses.)
Clause 19 deals with the procedure for making a Remuneration Authority determination. It requires the Remuneration Authority to—
seek the advice of the Speaker and the Minister responsible for Ministerial Services about the travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament and for Ministers respectively:
after seeking that advice, prepare a draft determination:
give members of Parliament and Ministers a reasonable opportunity to be heard on the draft:
consult the Commissioner of Inland Revenue about the proposed taxation consequences of the determination.
Subclause (2) requires the Authority to have regard to any advice given by the Speaker or the Minister responsible for Ministerial Services, but provides that it is not bound by any advice given.
Clause 20 empowers the Remuneration Authority to require information to be provided that it considers necessary for preparing a determination and also empowers it to obtain advice from persons it considers may assist the Authority in making its determination.
Clause 21 deals with publication of the Remuneration Authority's determinations. It requires the Authority to provide copies of every determination to the Prime Minister, the Speaker, the Leader of the Opposition, the Minister responsible for Ministerial Services, the chief executive of the Department of Internal Affairs, and the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service, and then requires the General Manager to ensure that a copy is made available on Parliament's Internet site as soon as practicable.
Clause 22 provides for the resolution of any issues that may arise concerning how a provision in a determination made by the Remuneration Authority is to be interpreted or applied or is to operate. It requires the Remuneration Authority to make the final determination of any such issues. However, subclause (2) empowers the Authority to prescribe procedures for resolving issues, including procedures that must be followed before an issue is referred to the Authority for final determination. These may involve the participation of the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service, in the case of issues about travel and accommodation entitlements of members of Parliament or qualifying electoral candidates, and the participation of the chief executive of the Department of Internal Affairs or the chief executive's nominee, in the case of issues about Ministers' entitlements.
Clause 23(1) is a permanent appropriation to provide funding for the travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament determined by the Remuneration Authority under clause 18 that are administered by the Parliamentary Service (see the note on clause 9 concerning the reason for permanent appropriations in relation to matters determined by the Remuneration Authority).
Clause 23(2) is a permanent appropriation to provide funding for the services determined by the Remuneration Authority under clause 18 that are administered by the Department of Internal Affairs.
Services and funding subject to Speaker's directions
Clauses 24 to 27 deal with services that the Speaker must determine and directions that he or she must issue relating to money appropriated in annual Appropriation Acts to support members' and parties' parliamentary operations (party and member support funding) and administrative and support services for members of Parliament, parties, and qualifying electoral candidates.
Clause 24 requires the Speaker to issue directions that set out—
the administrative and support services to be provided to members of Parliament, parties, and qualifying electoral candidates:
the entitlements of members of Parliament and qualifying electoral candidates to communications services:
how party and member support funding is allocated and how it must be administered, including what party and member support funding may be used for and what requirements have to be met before a payment may be made against a claim for funding by a member of Parliament, party, or qualifying electoral candidate.
Currently, the directions that the Speaker gives to the Parliamentary Service under section 7(b) of the Parliamentary Service Act 2000 concerning how the Service must administer the payment of funding entitlements for parliamentary purposes include provisions that cover these matters. The effect of the clause, in combination with clause 17, is that it becomes a statutory requirement that these matters be set out and that the Speaker have regard to the criteria specified in clause 17 when issuing directions on these matters:
the entitlements to travel services of members of Parliament nominated for participation in the political exchange programme.
The effect of subclauses (2) and (3) is that, other than travel services for members of Parliament participating in the political exchange programme or the inter-parliamentary relations programme and international travel and international accommodation services for Ministers, the only travel and accommodation services that may be provided for members of Parliament are—
those that have been determined by the Remuneration Authority:
international travel and international accommodation services where a member of Parliament is travelling internationally for parliamentary purposes and the costs of that travel are met from the party and member support funding appropriated for that member's party and are a charge against the leadership funding allocation. These services include travel and accommodation services for a party leader's spouse or partner if that person accompanies the party leader when he or she is travelling internationally for parliamentary purposes.
Clause 25 requires the Speaker, before issuing directions, to take into account any relevant advice given by the Parliamentary Service Commission under the Parliamentary Service Act 2000. It also requires the Speaker to consult the Minister responsible for Ministerial Services, the Remuneration Authority, and the Commissioner of Inland Revenue (about the taxation consequences of the proposed directions).
Clause 26 requires the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service to ensure that a copy of all directions are available on Parliament's Internet site as soon as practicable after they are issued.
Clause 27 provides for the resolution of any issues that may arise concerning how any direction issued by the Speaker under clause 24 is to be interpreted or applied or is to operate. It requires the Speaker to make the final determination of such issues. However, subclause (2) empowers the Speaker to prescribe procedures for resolving issues, including procedures that must be followed before the issue is referred to the Speaker for final determination. These may provide for the participation of the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service.
General provisions
Clauses 28 to 30 deal with general matters and are relevant to determinations made by the Remuneration Authority and directions issued by the Speaker.
Clause 28 provides that the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service may approve the conversion of an entitlement to a service determined by the Remuneration Authority under clause 18 or by the Speaker under clause 24 into a service costing a lesser amount, if the General Manager is satisfied that this service is for a parliamentary purpose and represents a fair return for the service provided.
Clause 29 deals with when determinations must be made and directions must be issued and also with the amendment of determinations and directions. It requires the Remuneration Authority to make a determination once in every term of Parliament, in the first 2 years of the term, and to consult the Speaker at the beginning of the term about the proposed timing of its determination for that term. Each determination continues in force until it is superseded by a new determination, although the Authority may amend a determination if it is satisfied that there are particular and special reasons that justify amending the determination, or to remedy defects, correct ambiguities, or deal with new matters that were not dealt with at the time the determination was made. These provisions also apply to the directions that the Speaker is required to issue under clause 24. However, under subclause (6), the Speaker has additional powers of amendment to deal with matters arising from changes that occur from year to year in the amounts appropriated for services and for party and member support funding and also to ensure the adequacy of administrative and support services for members of Parliament, parties, and qualifying electoral candidates.
Clause 30 requires quarterly reports to be prepared and published by the General Manager of the Parliamentary Service and the chief executive of the Department of Internal Affairs that set out details of expenses incurred to provide—
the travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament and Ministers determined by the Remuneration Authority:
the travel and accommodation services for members of Parliament travelling for parliamentary purposes that are not determined by the Remuneration Authority but are funded from party and member support funding and within directions issued by the Speaker in accordance with clause 24(3):
the travel services of members of Parliament nominated for participation in the political exchange programme.
Clauses 31 to 34 deal with the official inter-parliamentary relations programme (which is administered by the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives and funded from Vote Office of the Clerk).
Clause 31 requires the Speaker to determine the entitlements to travel and accommodation services in respect of members participating in this programme. Before making a determination, the Speaker must consult the Commissioner of Inland Revenue about the taxation consequences of the proposed determination. Subclause (3) provides for a determination to be made or amended at any time.
Clause 32 allows the Speaker's determination to provide for a member of Parliament to convert the member's entitlement to a travel service for certain purposes.
Clause 33 requires the Clerk of the House of Representatives to make a copy of every determination made under clause 31 available on Parliament's Internet site as soon as practicable after it is made.
Clause 34 requires the Clerk of the House of Representatives to prepare and publish quarterly reports setting out details of the expenses incurred to provide the travel and accommodation services for members participating in the inter-parliamentary relations programme.
Clause 35 relates to international travel, international accommodation, and communications services for Ministers. These are not determined by the Remuneration Authority (see the note on clause 18). However, if there is any significant change in the nature or extent of the services provided, the clause requires the Minister for the time being responsible for Ministerial Services to consult the Commissioner of Inland Revenue about the taxation consequences.
Part 4
Entitlements of former members and others and miscellaneous matters
Subpart 1—Entitlements of former members, former Prime Ministers, and others
Former members' entitlements
Clause 36 provides that a person who was a member of Parliament before the 1999 general election may continue to receive the travel entitlements (including the entitlements that apply to that person's spouse or partner) that are set out in Schedule 2. The entitlements set out in that schedule are the current travel entitlements of former members of Parliament except that the entitlements to road, rail, and ferry travel are no longer unlimited but are based on the same rebate system as applies for domestic air travel and are capped, in the same way as for domestic air travel, at 12 return trips per year. Also, travel for private business purposes is now expressly excluded in respect of these services.
Clause 36(2) makes it clear that no person who was elected as a member of Parliament for the first time at or after the 1999 general election may receive former member travel entitlements and that, in the case of a person who was elected before the 1999 general election, no service by the member of Parliament after 3 October 2008 is taken into account for the purposes of Schedule 2. The effect of the provision is, therefore, that only members of Parliament elected for the first time before the 1999 general election qualify for former member travel entitlements and those persons' travel entitlements are frozen at the level for which they qualified on 3 October 2008 (the end of the 2005 to 2008 parliamentary term).
Clause 37 disqualifies former members and the spouses and partners of former members from receiving the former member travel entitlements in Schedule 2 if, at the date the travel is taken, they have been convicted of certain crimes or have been reported by the court on the trial of an election petition to have been proved guilty of a corrupt practice and that crime or corrupt practice was committed during specified periods.
Clause 38 provides for any issues that arise about former members' eligibility for travel entitlements, or the interpretation, application, or operation of Schedule 2, to be determined by the Remuneration Authority.
Clause 39 requires a statement setting out specified details relating to the expenses incurred to provide former members' travel entitlements to be included in the annual financial statements of the Parliamentary Service.
Former Prime Ministers' entitlements
Clause 40 provides for the payment of an annuity to a former Prime Minister who held that office for at least 2 years at a yearly rate for each year of service up to and including 5 years of service. The annuity is payable at the rate fixed by the Remuneration Authority and must be paid until the person dies. The clause also provides for the payment of an annuity to the person's surviving spouse or partner. This is payable whether or not the spouse or partner remarries or re-partners. That annuity is payable, at half the rate at which the annuity would have been payable to the former Prime Minister, until the spouse or partner dies. Subclause (6) is a permanent appropriation to provide the funding for these annuities.
Clause 41 requires the Remuneration Authority to determine the entitlements to travel services within New Zealand of former Prime Ministers and their spouses or partners. The effect of subclause (2) is that any travel entitlements determined in respect of spouses and partners of former Prime Ministers continue after the former Prime Minister dies, regardless of whether the surviving spouse re-partners or remarries. Subclause (3) provides for any issues that arise about the Remuneration Authority's determination of entitlements to services under the clause to be determined by the Remuneration Authority. Subclause (4) is a permanent appropriation to provide the funding for these services.
Members of Parliament dying in office: Entitlements of family members
Clause 42 provides for the payment of a sum of money as income to a surviving spouse or partner or dependent child of a member of Parliament who dies while in office. This provision re-enacts section 23 of the Civil List Act 1979. Clause 9(4) is a permanent appropriation for any payments under clause 42.
Resolution of conflicting claims to entitlements
Clause 43 deals with how conflicting claims to the payment of an annuity under clause 40 or a payment under clause 42 must be resolved. This provision re-enacts section 27 of the Civil List Act 1979 with modifications so that it extends to the annuity payments under clause 40 as well as the payments under clause 42.
Subpart 2—Amendments to Parliamentary Service Act 2000
Clauses 44 to 55 make consequential amendments to the Parliamentary Service Act 2000.
Subpart 3—Amendments to Remuneration Authority Act 1977
Clauses 56 to 61 make consequential amendments to the Remuneration Authority Act 1977.
Subpart 4—Repeal, revocations, and consequential amendments
Clause 62 repeals the Civil List Act 1979.
Clause 63 revokes determinations made under the Civil List Act 1979.
Clause 64 makes the consequential amendments to other Acts specified in Schedule 3.
Subpart 5—Validations, savings, and transitional provision
Clause 65 relates to the validity of certain determinations of salaries and annuities made by the Remuneration Authority under the Civil List Act 1979 before the enactment of the Bill, and the validity of agreements to provide travel services for former Prime Ministers and their spouses and partners made before the enactment of the Bill. Subclause (2) requires certain salaries and allowances and annuities to continue to be paid at the rate applicable when the Bill is enacted until superseded by a determination of the Remuneration Authority under the new Act.
Clause 66 provides for the transition from the existing regime for the determination of entitlements to services to the new regime provided for in the Bill. The effect of the provision is that, for a transitional period of 12 months after the commencement of the Bill, all the existing entitlements of members of Parliament, members of the Executive, parties, and qualifying electoral candidates that the Remuneration Authority and the Speaker are required to determine are deemed to be the Authority's and the Speaker's determination of those entitlements. The Remuneration Authority and the Speaker are each required to make a determination of the entitlements within 12 months (which comes into force at the end of the transitional period), but each may amend existing entitlements at any time before making that determination. The same transitional arrangement applies in respect of directions issued by the Speaker in respect of party and member support funding and administrative and support services that must be provided to members of Parliament, parties, and qualifying electoral candidates.